Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Sachin or Laxman?

Durban, where we were bamboozled for a paltry 66 fourteen years back was conquered yesterday. And boy, it was conquered in some style. The image of an arched Jacques Kallis, helplessly trying to avoid a Sreesanth snorter would be etched in the memories of every Indian cricket fan. Fantastic stuff boys, keep up the good work.
Happens to a South African too
While Zaheer, Bhajji and Sree were exceptional with the ball, it was that man VVS again who set up the game for them. Scoring 96 sublime runs on a pitch where every other batsman was found wanting was something quite extraordinary. Well, as they say, when the going gets tough, Laxman gets going.

It was disappointing though, to notice swords being drawn on SRT (again!!) for failing when the team needed him the most. Statistics were dug up in order to prove how Laxman is a far better batsman than Tendulkar when the chips are down. Glorifying Laxman’s performances while berating Tendulkar’s was totally uncalled for. Not everybody knows the fact that out of his 50 Test hundreds, 20 have resulted in an Indian win. Not everybody knows that out of his 46 ODI hundreds, 32 have resulted in wins. I could have jotted down thousands of statistics just to prove that he has been India’s biggest match winner ever, but refrained from doing so, as it would have provided more fodder for the so called “Tendulkar critics” to dig up some more stats and figures to downplay the man’s contribution to Indian Cricket. He failed at Durban because he is a human, just like you and me. He had an off day at the office, but made sure that his end of year reviews were totally in the top bracket. Over 1500 runs with an outstanding average of 78, not everybody delivers a performance of that stature consistently over a period of 21 years.

“Oh, he failed right? Then why call him God”? Tendulkar worshipers don’t call him God just because they expect him to win every game for India with his divine presence. Like we believe in the creator of all universes, we believe in him. As long as he is at the crease, impossible seems possible, living up to the tagline of one of the brands he endorses. In the 90's, he was the one who used to give us hope when the rub of the green seemed to be going against our way. Not every 17 year old can bat for 6 hours on a seaming Old Trafford track to save a test match for India. It’s only when he departs, the panic sets in, the nervousness starts showing in the form of chewing of nails and wrinkles on the forehead. Remember the 1996 World Cup semifinal against the Lankans? Or the nail biter at Chennai against the arch rivals? Or the most recent Hyderabad hurricane against the Aussies? Impossible was made possible on countless other occasions, only to be made impossible again by the individuals who surround him.

It’s probably only under these situations that even a half century from somebody else looks more valuable than “those” 96 international tons. We expect him to hit a ton every innings, we expect him to stay on the crease till the last run is scored and we expect him to chase down 360 to win the World Cup. Isn't that a little too much? Probably, that's the benchmark the man has set, something which even Laxman and Dravid have failed to do so.We expect him to be accountable for every time he fails to deliver the goods while we forget that it’s a team game afterall. The same Laxman failed when India were battling hard to save the Centurion test, but it went down as an another innings where a Tendulkar century had failed to save India. I am just wondering, had India lost the Durban test, who would have been crucified then? 

It’s high time we appreciate what these men of steel have done for Indian Cricket, rather than baying for their blood every time they fail. Trust me, you would never have a batting line-up as strong as the one which has mesmerized crowds the world over in a long long time. Let’s savor their heroic feats before they decide to hang their boots, because I still feel, that majority of us are incapable of achieving even half of the glory these men have achieved.

P.S. Happy New Year Guys ! :)

13 comments:

  1. Happy new year dude ...and screw the critics ! :P ...nyways u made my time a lil better for some minutes at offc ;)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice read..but very little mention of Laxman does not do justice to your subject "Sachin or LAXMAN"

    ReplyDelete
  3. @ Anand : thanks ..and yes,Laxman hasn't been mentioned in a great deal, coz I didn't intend to do stat comparisons between the two as it would have been disrespectful to the two gems of this era...
    the point I want to make is that both have saved/won matches for India a number of times,but we tend to highlight Tendulkar's failures..but we cleverly choose to ignore those matches where the rest fail and the master delivers ! Can't understand this hypocrisy ....

    ReplyDelete
  4. sir ji.. so true.. "Impossible was made possible on countless other occasions, only to be made impossible again by the individuals who surround him." says it all.. now the critics sud go thru theses lines.. :D

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have always thought of not commenting on your blogs for a reason you and me already know.. but I cant let go this one I guess..
    1) I dno abt all but you - as a Sachin fan are living in a hypothetical world where people around you whisper ill of Sachin because he did not bat well in a game.. nothing of that sort happened after this game and you are just bloating it out of proportions.. I did not even read ur stats para because wtever you say about Sachin is less - Respect! (i can safely assume that those stats was to prove his Godliness). We shall talk perceptions here and not numbers
    2) Totally agree with Anand.. You are again belittling Laxman's performance by imagining virtual swords being drawn at your God (perception issue again, not numbers). Let go your blog, your blog title is enough to ruin Laxman's credit! You cant let people rejoice when India wins because of anybody else other than Sachin. Can you? Sachin would himself be ashamed of your remarks and you have got to learn some humility from him
    3) "It’s only when he departs, the panic sets in, the nervousness starts showing in the form of chewing of nails and wrinkles on the forehead." Talk about your own self.. People still believe important contributors after him.. and that is why people watched Indian innings till the end without a sign of Hypertension
    4) "He failed at Durban because he is a human" - Exactly my point.. I conclude majesty!

    Disclaimer - No personal offense. "You" here refers to all Sachin fans staying in their own little world refusing to see the game beyond a man..

    PS - Happy new year! :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think Hanu's comment is more fun to read (and true for sure) than the blog!
    Is there a like button on this button I am not aware of!
    @Jayesh: I hope you remember, Cricket is still a team game with 11 players (don't miss the second 1 of 11)!

    ReplyDelete
  7. @ Hanu : I feel privileged and honor to see your comments on my blog :) (lets celebrate that with some OMR at your place tomorrow :P)

    All of us over here agree to the fact that it's a team game, but do we even remember the times Sachin baled out when Laxman failed?? NO ACT OF DISRESPECT to either of the greats, coz I did not dig into mindless stats to belittle their achievements...As an Indian Cricket fan, I have stayed up late nights to watch the Indian team failing to chase 120 at Bridgetown, I had witnessed the team fold at 100 and 66 at Durban 14 years ago, Yes Tendulkar has been a god to many (including me),but that has never affected someone who would watch a tough cricket match even between Bangladesh and Zimbabwe. Trust me, I have did this...All through the 90's, I have seen the team fold when he departed coz the others just din't have a will to win from impossible situations..

    I have cared about performances..Tendulkar scoring a ton ..and the rest folding like ten pins didn't do justice to the man...he deserved to be on the winning side...Laxman is just a metaphor..Still can't figure out why "anybody" who performs when he fails is suddenly put a pedestal above him? Why do we choose to forget the countless times when he won the game for us? Why do we remember only that "4" he scored at Jo'burg while forgetting that it was his 669 runs before the final that brought us to that stage? I have jumped as much as anybody else when VVs scored that 281 against the Aussies..And why go that far, remember the Mohali Test which we watched together in the office ..praying for every single run which Laxman and Ishant scored...Trust me..we may love a man ...but we still love our cricket !

    Read this article by Allan Donald, WV Raman and Venkatesh Prasad..this was the Indian Team of the 90's .....when Tendulkar used to score ..only to see the initiative squandered by the rest ..

    http://www.espncricinfo.com/south-africa-v-india-2010/content/current/story/494682.html

    ReplyDelete
  8. @ sania : Thanks for your feedback..but seriously..when was the last time you actually watched a cricket match? I mean watched..din't just check the scores on Cricinfo?

    No offence, but you belong to the league of all those extra-ordinary gentlemen for whom this blog was meant ! Period :)

    P.S. : I do know it's a 11 a side game..known since the time I have seen this man bat ..(1992 perhaps) ...and that's the only reason I have consoled myself whenever I saw him perform and the rest falter...Just wished the same treatment from his critics...but alas ...He has just set the benchmarks so so high !

    ReplyDelete
  9. @hanu - points well made.

    @J - good you mentioned that cricket is a team game. It's sad that many people think that "It’s only when he departs, the panic sets in..."

    No-one has ever doubted that Sachin is good, even great. But seriously, Sachin is not a match-saver. He's a match winner and that, my friend, is different. I cant remember the last time he "saved" a match the way VVS has...

    I only wish Sachin fans had half the humility he has. Once again, recapping some of my thoughts on Sachin and his fans...
    http://blitheringidiotbox.blogspot.com/2010/04/of-believers-and-believer-haters.html

    ReplyDelete
  10. I saw this comment somewhere in cricinfo ,"Some people(like SRT, Ponting) the longer they play, loose fans but some like VVS, they add to it."

    My take is similar.Sachin is like USA,it already achieved a lot, expectations are high and growth rates are low. Laxman is like China, overpopulated ( read as back problem,lack of ODI/T20 agression et al) commie country achieving all that is heart warming. So people tend to support him more.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. @J: Just to clarify.. watching a match with some extra-extra-ordinary people (who are datawarehouse of how many steps Sachin has taken to reach the field) is not my cup of tea. I like to watch things with PEACE!
    and as you think there is only one player you might as well think there is only one sport..
    I give same respect to other sports as well!!

    ReplyDelete
  13. @ sania : peace out be ! We can never agree on something ..can we ? :)

    ReplyDelete